RECRUITMENT AND SELECTION PROCESSES IN AUSTRALIA AND CHINA: REWARDS FROM COMMON SENSE AND PLAIN DEALING.
Carolyn Dickie, Curtin Business School, Curtin University of Technology Laurence Dickie, Curtin Business School, Curtin University of Technology
Western practices of recruitment and selection are not transferable, easily or automatically, by multi-national or local companies entering the economically vibrant Chinese market. In the current paper, Western HR functions are compared with Eastern, Chinese approaches; the major finding being that, although similar language is used to describe HR processes, cultural factors affect the practices differently.
Since introducing a market economy in 1978, China has been one of the fastest growing economies in Asia. In recent times expansion has occurred throughout the world, and interest in China has exploded to the stage where China fever is a world-wide syndrome. Furthermore, with its entry into the World Trade Organisation in 2001, China was immediately recognised as one of the world’s economic superpowers.
By the turn of the century, China was reported to command in excess of a forty-two percent share of all foreign investment in Asia (Glover & Siu, 2000). Similarly, in 2000, there were over sixty thousand foreigners living in the capital city of Beijing, the focal point for Chinese commerce (Yu, 2001). Many more operated in cities across the country, a majority of whom were employed by multinational companies and brought with them western management practices (Ding et al., 2000). Thus, in China, there has arisen an awareness of the need to adopt more effective human management practices in state-owned enterprises (Ding et al., 2000), to influence the lives of consumers, employees and citizens (Fishman, 2005) through its rapidly changing, reformed economy; an activity which presents some interesting challenges to organisations, employers and employees.
In the West, studies conducted in the United States and the United Kingdom have demonstrated a causal link between the operation of human resource management practices and organisational performance (Huselid, 1995; MacDuffie, 1995; Ichniowski et al., 1996; Patterson et al., 1998). These studies concluded that coherent, integrated human resource techniques lead to increased output, productivity and overall organisational performance. However, less is known about changing HR issues in China, and introducing change to traditional state-owned enterprises may prove to be far more complex and difficult than introducing them into newly established multinational organisations.
The constrained enthusiasm of the new generation of Chinese managers towards learning Western management practices (Gamble, 2000) is understandable and, as suggested by Purcell (1999), there is the need for a careful study of organisational contexts before ambitions to integrate Western and Eastern HR practices may be considered realistic. One of the most important aspects of organisational context is having an understanding of current practices in the two management styles.
Consequently, the purpose in the current paper was to compare the ‘Western’ human resource functions of recruitment and selection with the ‘Eastern’ approaches used in China. An overview of the culture of both China and Australia was included and an examination of the current recruitment and selection practices was undertaken.
As a young nation which became federated in 1901, Australia is a member of the British Commonwealth with an approximate population of twenty million people primarily located in a few major urbanised cities. The vast majority of people (93%) is Caucasian and the predominant language is English. Asians comprise only 7% of its total population (World Factbook, 2005). Australia, being rich in natural resources, has built in only 100 years a strong economy with a per capita GDP...
References: Benson, J. (1996) “The sleeping giant happens no more (State-owned enterprises in China:
recent changes in human resource management),”.People Management, 2 (12), 22-26.
Benson, J. and Zhu,Y. (1999) “Markets, firms and workers in Chinese state-owned
Enterprises,” Human Resource Management Journal, 9 (4), 58-74.
Bond, M.H. (1991) Beyond the Chinese Face, Hong Kong: Oxford University Press.
Borkman, I. and Lu, Y. (1999) “The management of human resources in Chinese-Western
joint ventures,” Journal of World Business, 34 (3), 306-324.
Bucalo, J.P. (1983) “Good advertising can be more effective than other recruitment tools,”
Personal Administrator, 28, 739.
Chatterjee, S. and Nankervis, A. (2003) Understanding Asian Management: Transition and
Transformation, Perth: Vineyard Publishing.
Child, J. (1994) Management in China During the Age of Reform, Cambridge: Cambridge
Compton, R.L. (1996) “Interviewing – facts and fantasies”, Recruiting to Gain the
Competitive Edge Conference, Sydney & Melbourne.
Crawford, R.B. (2004) “Recruitment and Selection,” HR Research Paper No 30, 12 pages,
HRDOC Store: London.
Ding, D., Goodall, K. and Warner, M. (2000) “The end of the ‘iron rice-bowl’: wither
Chinese human resource management?” International Journal of Human Resource
Fishman, T.C. (2005) China Inc. How the rise of the next superpower challenges America in
the World, New York: Scriber.
Gamble J. (2000) “Localising management in foreign-invested enterprises in China: practical,
cultural and strategic perspectives”
Gao, G., Ting-Toomey, S. and Godykunst, W.B. (1996) Chinese Communication Process,
Hong Kong: Oxford University Press.
Gill, C. (2000) “Talent Wins,” HR Monthly, April, 34-36.
Glover, L. and Siu, N. (2000) “The human resource barriers to managing quality in China,”
International Journal of Human Resource Management, 11 (5), 867-882.
Goodall, K. and Warner, M. (1997) “Human resources in Sino-foreign joint ventures: selected
case studies in Shanghai compared with Beijing,” Journal of International Human Resource Management, 8 (5), 569-594.
Goldrick, P. (1997) “What makes a selection system best practice?” HR Monthly, June,
Huffcult, A.I. and Arthur, W. (1994) “Interview validity for entry-level jobs,” Journal of
Applied Psychology, 79, 184-190
Huselid, M. (1995) “The impact of human resource management practices on turnover,
productivity and corporate financial performance,” Academy of Management Journal, 38 (3), 635-672.
Ichnioowski, C., Kochan, T., Levin, D., Olsen, C. and Strauss, G. (1996) “What works at
work: overview and assessment,” Industrial Relations, 35 (3), 299-333.
Ip, D. (1995) “Trailblazing into China: networks and linkages of smaller diaspora firms,”
Asia Research Centre, Perth: Murdoch University.
Lewis, P. (2003) “New China – old ways? A case study of the prospects of for implementing
human resource management practices in a Chinese state-owned enterprise,” Employee Relations, 25 (1/2), 42-61.
Loong, C. (2004a) (m.d.) Doing business in Shanghai 2004, Singapore: China Knowledge Pte
Loong, C. (2004b) (m.d.) Doing business in Beijing 2004, Singapore: China Knowledge Pte`
McComb, R. (1999) “2009 – China’s human resource odyssey,” The China Business Review,
MacDuffe, J. (1995) “Human resource bundles and manufacturing performance
organisational logic and flexible production systems in the world auto industry,”
Michael, B. (1993) “Tips on recruiting,” The CPA Journal, p.76 [Retrieved 23rd March, 2005,
from ABI_INFORM database]
Mondy, R.W. and Noe, R.M. (1993) Human Resorce Management, New York: Allyn &
Nankervis, A., Compton, R. and Baird, M. (2002) Strategic Human Resource Management,
Overman, S. (2001) “Recruitment in China,” HRMagazine, 46, p.86 [Retrieved 23rd March,
2005 from ABI-INFORM database]
Patterson, M., West, M. Hawthorn, R. and Nickell, S. (1998) “Impact of people management
practices on business performance,” Issues in People Management, No 22, Institute of Personnel and Development: Wimbledon.
Purcell, J. (1999) “Best practice and best fit: chimera or cul-de-sac?” Human Resource
Management Journal, 9 (3), 26-41.
Rafaeli, A. and Oliver, A.L. (1998) “Employment ads: a configurational research agenda”.
Schermerhorn, J.R. (2002) Management, New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Sensenbrenner, J.S. and Sensenbrenner, J. (1994) ‘Personnel Priorities,’ The China Business
Review, 21, 40 [Retrieved 23rd March, 2005 ABI-INFORM database].
Sudhir, K.S. (1993) “Managing human resources: China vs the West,” Canadian Journal of
Administrative Sciences, 167-177 [Retrieved 23rd March, 2005 ABI-INFORM database].
Taylor, H. (2003) Hofstede cultural dimensions [ Retrieved 4th April, 2005,
UPS (2003) China Business Handbook, London: Alain Charles Publishing Ltd.
The World Factbook (2003) “China”. [Retrieved 2nd August, 2005, ABI-INFORM database].
Verma, A. and Zhiming, Y. (1995) “The changing face of human resource management in
China: opportunities, problems and strategies” in Verma, A., Kochan, T
Warner, M. (1995) “Managing China’s human resources,” Human Systems Management,
Yu, P.K. (2001) “The ramifications of China’s entry into the World Trade Organisation: Will
the Global Community Benefit?” Findlaw’s Legal Commentary, [Retrieved 2nd August, 2005, ABI-INFORM database].
Vanhonacker, W.R. (2004) “Guanxi networks in China,” The China Business Review, 48
[Retrieved 23rd March, 2005 ABI-INFORM database].
Xin, K.R. and Pearce, J.L. (1996) “Guanxi connections as substitutes for formal institutional
Support,” Academy of Management Journal, 39 (6), 1641-1658.
Zhu, Y. (1995) “Major changes under way in China’s industrial relations,” International
Labour Review, 134 (1), 37-49.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document